I have scans of an art doujinshi I would like to post, but I'd like some opinions first. I've noticed that some people post every page of a doujinshi. This particular doujin is mostly color, but it also includes some sketches, index pages, images of males only (which I know many people here dislike:P), and two pages of airplane drawings.

So my question is, how many people here think I should upload the "good stuff" only, and how many people would prefer I upload the whole thing for the sake of completeness?

For me personally, I'll take anything as long as it's within the art style I like, male or female. But I do know most of the users here are males so I refrain from posting male images, even though I see some amazing ones that I think even our male audience would like. (don't ask me to post them, I collect just too many images now and looking for it would be a hassle ^^)

I do believe the sketches will do fine too, since i've seen some sketches here and no one have yet to complain about them. But for index pages, I would say don't post them since they have no illustration value once so ever, and I would also say no for the airplane also unless it has a character smacked on it.

I think male posts are mostly pointless, but harmless; just be sure to tag it male.

If you're posting full sets, be sure to pool them. If you want to include less interesting pages for completeness that only collectors are likely to care about (within reason), then parent those pages under the title page as well as pooling them; they'll show up in the pool, but not the index. I only recommend this for things that really do have no value in casual browsing, like indexes.

As long as it isn't hardcore guy on guy stuff I don't really care....others might though

lol, don't worry, there is no male pornography...only female. Anyway, petopeto's suggestion is pretty good, so I'll do just that. I'll upload when I have time. I appreciate everyone's input.

I don't see problem with sketches and index pages as long somebody want them, it is not hard to jump over them. Maybe sketch and index tags could be added so peoples can blacklist them if they want.

I actualy would like to have scans of males as long it is not hardcore Shōnen-ai